Ask-The-Contestants!
Send your question to [email protected]
Question of the Week: "Proportional Representation voting. What is your plan to get there?"
The Green Party of Canada favours a Proportional Representation (PR) electoral system as the method that most accurately reflects the will of the electorate.
What is your plan to achieve fair voting in Canadian elections?
- Vivian Unger - Fredericton, NB
This section is for the contestants to participate in, only.
They can respond to the members' questions and/or discuss between themselves.
Contestant responses will be visible in the comments section, below.
Report inappropriate content
Is this content inappropriate?
Close debate
What is the summary or conclusion of this debate?
Comment details
You are seeing a single comment
View all comments
As you will see on my full platform, sarahgabriellebaron.ca, which has been available to members since the first week of the race, I take my cue on democratic reform directly from the members, as we should in a Green organization committed to the Key Value of Participatory Democracy.
Since 2014 our Member-made policy says clearly that, “the GPC Executive develop, as soon as possible, a preferred model of proportional representation, including a high degree of proportionality.” (GPC Policy Book, page 19)
The excuse “Proportional Representation is too confusing, Canadians aren’t ready” no longer washes with the Greens.
In my platform and in my Six Month Plan I propose weekly Policy Table Talks where members will pick one form of proportional representation. We will have this motion in front of the membership at our next policy conference, hopefully by June 2023 or sooner. Once we have chosen one form of PR, I will ensure every candidate and spokesperson is well-versed in the same talking points, so we have cohesive political messaging as we sell this PR version to the nation.
Fundamentally, we need to exemplify fair democratic reform in a rules-based system from within. Our constitution used to require timed leadership races every 4 years. In 2010 Elizabeth May argued during our Biannual General meeting to kill that rule. I was the last Green at the microphone begging members to not disown our commitment to Participatory Democracy. But, with stars in our eyes, we followed Elizabeth’s lead, because, I quote, she said she would be “too busy” and her aide argued, “this is the way the other parties do it.”
If our leader isn’t a champion of Participatory Democracy from within, how can we pretend our organization is a champion on the national stage?
Who among your leadership race options exemplifies a heritage of devotion to Participatory Democracy? Here is my resume:
under Jim Harris, collaborated with the then international affairs Shadow Cabinet critic. I bring it back, with a promise that your Shadow Cabinet reps will host a Policy Table Talk at least once per month.
was a strong critic of the 2018 methods limiting us to just 15 generically-worded motions
was part of the ad-hoc Constitution Working Group that ensured we did not allow such undemocratic, limiting rules in our 2020 process.
reminded Federal Council in spring of 2020 that it was a policy year,
proposed a constitutional change to evolve our member-led process from biannual to annual, which members approved of by 83%.
provides a clear plan to evolve our organization to a continual “living” policy process that is still member-led.
was an early adopter in 2021 of the interactive web application you are on right now!
Perhaps most shockingly, we have four leaders in this race who circumvent our member-led constitutional amendment process, and promote the idea of dual-leader as if it already exists. How hypocritical is it, to pretend this race is rules-based and democratically fair, when you get to vote for Elizabeth’s vision twice, for Chad and Anna’s vision twice, but for my vision for the party only once?
If we can not be true to our own constitution, we have no business asking Canadians to put their faith in us.
A shift to Proportional Representation, towards a democratic system where citizens feel in control of the decisions that affect their lives, can only be led by Greens if we start from within.
If members are ready to elect a leader that puts the collective first at every turn, then they will find my promise the fastest route to getting PR in Canada: choose one form of proportional representation in the next few months, and then be election-ready to sell this PR form to Canadians by a likely summer 2023 election.
Loading comments ...