Motion to standardize electric vehicle EV battery design for reparability also standing against planned obsolescence in all devices
- Introductory Statement
- Whereas consumer protest against EV adoption focuses on their kilometer range, battery cost and probable expensive failure, AND WHEREAS commercial electric vehicles present insurmountable problems with battery range and efficacy for business transportation using EV charging stations as their only means of refueling, AND WHEREAS past experience in the 1980s has shown the enormous benefit of standardization of the IBM PC hardware and MS DOS software and many other highly technical devices we recommend the following
- Emergency Motion Statement
- BE IT RESOLVED that the Green Party insist that the Standards Council of Canada (SCC) be called upon to review, recommend and advise for legislation by the Parliament of Canada to enable battery changeout design to be standardized by hardware machinery and software design to enable compatibility across all consumer model electric vehicles similar to computer standardization as per past and declining practices in that industry. AND BE IT RESOLVED that the Green Party stands against all means of planned obsolescence in the EV industry and other industries that prevent the most affordable and timely repair of electric vehicles and other devices by legislation if necessary.
- Type of Emergency Motion
- Public policy that the party would represent
- Benefit
- Benefits include: Reduced emissions by increase desirability and adoption of electric vehicles. Affordable reparability of EV vehicles by standardized maintenance through design. Affordable reparability of single cell failure of EV batteries where one cell fails in any given multicell design.
- Who does this motion impact?
- Impacts all Canadians Potentially impacts all EV commercial and consumer vehicle designs worldwide Government opposition to planned obsolescence enabling redirection in manufacturing
- Impact on exisiting GPC policy.
- New policy.
- Green Values
-
SustainabilityEcological Wisdom
- Supporting Evidence
- The ever increasing poverty of engineering design HAS BEEN WITNESSED by the mover of this motion through 40 years of EXPERIENCE in industrial maintenance as an electronics engineering technician, a mechanic, an industrial electrician and likewise a computer repair technician. Consumers are fully aware of planned obsolesce and poor design evidenced by public movement to make all consumer items more repairable The CAMI commercial delivery vehicle GM factory in Ingersoll Ontario remain in extended layoff and shutdown through poor availability and poor design that enables only 4-6 hours of EV use before a required recharge
- Jurisdiction: Is this proposal under federal jurisdiction?
- Yes
- Please indicate the language the proposal is being submitted in.
- English
This proposal has been rejected because:
This motion failed to meet the 66.6% threshold of support needed to be considered as an emergency motion. Therefore, this motion was not presented for consideration by membership.
We're building a new kind of politics. One that is open, participatory, and people-powered
If you believe in what we're doing, please consider making a small donation to help us build it
Report inappropriate content
Is this content inappropriate?
Comment details
You are seeing a single comment
View all comments
Conversation with Randy Randy Schelhas
That is reasonable Mark. Knowing that we have studied the problem somewhat and we will be fighting for improved recycling is what I needed to understand.
The other part of my motion regarding planned obsolescence deals with too much worthless junk coming in from China and other countries is still up in the air with your answer. My wife's keyboard on her laptop was incapable of being removed (because the whole top was molded in one piece) last fall when our cockatiel picked off many of the keys. The laptop is junk now and I provided her with a better older model for an upgrade.
I repaired computers for 3 years about 10 years ago and I've dismantled laptops completely down to soldering the power plug. I believe people who must throw digital equipment in the garbage because it is unrepairable hate that. I think the planned obsolesce motion can still be a demographic vote winner (particularly among seniors) from consumers.
What say you? Can we split the motion for reconsideration?
That's fine with me Randy. I believe you're on board with what I said. Please go ahead with your changes. Thanks.
Looking again there is a mistake regarding cell phones and extremely small electronic devices.
I would like to amend the following.
AND WHEREAS bulky modern electronic devices are no longer repairable in an estimated ninety five percent of designs with heavy mass.
Awaiting your feedback
Randy Schelhas
Here is the rewritten motion focusing upon electronic planned obsolescence as a whole.
WHEREAS past experience in the 1980s has shown the enormous economic benefit of standardization of the IBM PC hardware and MS DOS software and many other highly technical devices we recommend the following
AND WHEREAS modern electronic devices are no longer repairable in an estimated ninety five percent of designs and circumstances.
BE IT RESOLVED that the Green Party stands against planned obsolescence of manufactured devices by legislation if necessary.
Who does this motion impact?
Impacts all Canadians
Potentially impacts electronic designs worldwide
Government opposition to planned obsolescence enabling sustainable redirection in manufacturing
Impact on existing GPC policy.
New policy.
Green Values
Sustainability
Ecological Wisdom
Supporting Evidence:
Municipal landfill site have enormous numbers of computers, Xboxes, Televisions generally being placed in shipping containers for offshore recycling. As a skilled electronics engineering technician the presenter of this motion has experienced increasing non-reparability of these devices as they used to be all repairable in earlier years or decades.
I'm sorry for nitpicking on this issue.
Seeing the plight of starving people being murdered in Gaza is bothering me.
You guys should know that I spied on a coffee meeting with MP Larry Brock locally in Brantford on Saturday to get an impression of him.
I also taped a half hour TV segment with Rogers community channel on Monday explaining how I was able to own 8 duplexes (including 3 in Niagara Falls NY) providing affordable rents while paying all the utilities. It should begin airing in a month or so. Making other strategies too.
Loading comments ...